Dessert · sweet

Secret Ingredient Fudge

I’ve never been a big fan of fudge, but there are some people in my family who love it. Because of that, I usually have to make it for the holidays so they can enjoy it.

My mom and I have used the same fudge recipe for years. It’s known as “fantasy fudge” or “miracle fudge” and is made with marshmallow cream. It’s an easy way to make the sweet treat and the marshmallow cream is a good shortcut to thickening it up and binding the ingredients together.

But, what if I told you there was an even EASIER way to make fudge? You don’t have to melt any chocolate, and the hardest part is stirring for a few minutes.

The only problem: this fudge recipe uses a bizarre ingredient that might turn some people off. You can just keep it a secret, in that case.

The secret ingredient? Velveeta cheese.

Using Velveeta In Fudge

I’m not sure where the use of Velveeta in fudge came from. It’s a tried and true recipe, though, and a lot of time you see it made in the Midwest.

SEE ALSO: Pretzel Peanut Butter Balls

I’ve found recipes in plenty of old church cookbooks from the 70s and 80s.

Velveeta’s processed nature give the fudge a smooth texture and makes it ultra creamy. You can’t taste the “cheese” at all, because let’s be honest—Velveeta doesn’t really have a taste.

On top of that, this recipe uses TWO POUNDS, yes, TWO POUNDS of powdered sugar. Any funky cheese taste is covered up by that.

Velveeta is the ultimate ingredient because it melts evenly, is easy to use, and gives you a better textured fudge that isn’t easy to replicate using natural ingredients.

Packaging the Fudge

I always use the same square pan for fudge-making. Most people use 8×8″ or 9×9″ square pans so the fudge can be cut into thick pieces.

Once you’ve spooned you fudge mixture into the pan, I recommend pressing it down with a sheet of parchment paper to give it an even texture. Let it sit out on the kitchen counter for a few hours to set, then cut into squares.

SEE ALSO: Hot Cocoa Puppy Chow

WARNING: this fudge is THICK so it can be hard to cut! You need a steak knife or butter knife and a good grip to cut it.

I like to package up the fudge into cute little Christmas containers for storage or gifting. People will love this fudge, just maybe withhold the piece of information that it’s made with Velveeta!

Secret Ingredient Fudge

  • Servings: 10-12
  • Difficulty: Easy
  • Print

A creamy, smooth chocolate fudge made with a secret ingredient.

Ingredients

  • 2 pounds powdered sugar
  • 1/2 cup cocoa
  • 2 sticks (1 cup) butter
  • 8 oz Velveeta
  • 1/2 cup chopped walnuts
  • Directions

    1. In a large saucepan, melt butter over medium heat. Add Velveeta, cubed up, and stir. Continue cooking, stirring constantly, until Velveeta is melted. Remove from heat.
    2. In a large bowl sift together powdered sugar and cocoa powder. Slowly add a few cupfuls of the powdered sugar mixture to the melted Velveeta mixture, stirring constantly. Mixture will get extremely thick, but continue stirring with a wooden spoon. Add in walnuts near the end of the additions of powdered sugar. Stir until well combined.
    3. Spoon fudge mixture into a well greased square baking dish. Press down evenly (put a sheet of parchment paper over fudge and press down with hands). Let fudge sit on counter for a few hours to set. Cut into 12-15 squares.

    2 thoughts on “Secret Ingredient Fudge”

    Leave a Reply